The Old Catholic Church is the specific historical movement that rejected the 1870 First Vatican Council’s decrees on papal infallibility. In contrast, “Independent Catholic” is a broad, umbrella term encompassing any Catholic-tradition church, including Old Catholics, that operates entirely outside the authority of the Roman Catholic Church.
The relationship between the two terms can be broken down into their origins, core governance, and theology.
Core Differences
- The Movement: Old Catholics are a specific denomination founded in Europe (such as the Union of Utrecht). Independent Catholicism is a vast, loose global movement of thousands of different unaffiliated jurisdictions, microchurches, and individual priests
- Historical Timeline: The Old Catholic Church emerged in 1870, specifically in response to the dogma of Papal Infallibility. Independent Catholic churches can originate from this 1870 split, or they could be much more recent breakaways protesting Vatican II (e.g., conservative traditionalists) or progressive groups protesting modern Vatican policies.
Key Characteristics
Feature
Authority
Theology
Apostolic Succession
Roman Status
Old Catholic Church
Governed by regional synods and bishops (e.g., Union of Utrecht)
Generally progressive. They practice open communion, allow married priests, and many ordain women.
Highly organized; recognized by the Anglican Communion and generally accepted by Rome as valid.
Considered schismatic by the Vatican, but valid in their sacraments.
Independent Catholic
Varies wildly; many are completely self-governing and accountable only to their local bishop or founder.
Highly diverse. Can range from extremely progressive/inclusive (like the Reformed Catholic Church) to fiercely traditionalist/Latin-Mass focused.
Unregulated. While many lines of succession can be traced, validity depends heavily on the specific bishop who performed the ordination.
Unrecognized by the Vatican, with sacraments that may or may not be deemed valid depending on the specific group.
Discover more from Third Order of Franciscans of the Eucharist
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.